510 New Rule for The Donald. If someone Says we should do X and you point out the flaw in the idea, you must reply with an alternate solution. It is EASY to Shit on Ideas. Being part of the solution is harder. posted 89 days ago by MaxItout 89 days ago by MaxItout +514 / -4 That is all. 70 comments share 70 comments share save hide report block hide child comments Comments (70) sorted by: top new old worst You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread. ▲ 3 ▼ – PieceOfParchment7 3 points 89 days ago +3 / -0 Pointing out flaws is an integral part of science. Supplying a solution isn't necessary. permalink save report block reply ▲ 1 ▼ – MaxItout [S] 1 point 89 days ago +1 / -0 Galileo would disagree with you on that. permalink parent save report block reply ▲ 2 ▼ – PieceOfParchment7 2 points 89 days ago +2 / -0 Guessing isn't science. permalink parent save report block reply ▲ 0 ▼ – MaxItout [S] 0 points 89 days ago +1 / -1 no, it is not science. But you can bring even a small argument to talk it over. you can bring forth a hypothesis. And it can be disproven or ruled unprovable. I can say any zany idea I want. See the Star Trek teleporter example in this thread. permalink parent save report block reply ▲ 1 ▼ – PieceOfParchment7 1 point 89 days ago +1 / -0 My only point was that just because a person can't pair their criticism with a solution does not mean their criticism is null and void. Do you remember the OP? permalink parent save report block reply
Pointing out flaws is an integral part of science.
Supplying a solution isn't necessary.
Galileo would disagree with you on that.
Guessing isn't science.
no, it is not science. But you can bring even a small argument to talk it over. you can bring forth a hypothesis. And it can be disproven or ruled unprovable. I can say any zany idea I want. See the Star Trek teleporter example in this thread.
My only point was that just because a person can't pair their criticism with a solution does not mean their criticism is null and void.
Do you remember the OP?