yes, but they don't get to make up in their head regardless of all order and command structure, who and what tyranny is.
To say that they should disobey tyranny does about much good practically speaking as saying "Do Good and Avoid Evil".....it's a bit more complicated than that and guess what, human beings are social animals so we exist in hierarchies and in associations that are structured. That means we generally follow rules, obey orders and look to cues around us to know what to do. We don't expect a room full of sixth graders to rise up and overthrow a marxist teacher and we don't expect soldiers to disobey orders because "muh oathkeeper narrative".
Soldiers don't determine what a legal or illegal order is for the most part. Just as law enforcement isn't going to argue the finer points of law while arresting someone they think is a criminal. Stop trying to pretend that every single person that works in law enforcement and the U.S. Armed Forces has to be a Constitutional lawyers. This isn't how life works. We don't go to our job with a lawyer attached at the hip weighing the legality and morality of every decision. okay, well, people who don't spend the day praying don't do that. People who pray unceasingly do that but spiritually.
Their immediate duty is to follow orders, not to live out your fantasy of instigating a black pilled Civil War. Knock if off with this bullschiff!
Their immediate duty is to disobey tyranny.
yes, but they don't get to make up in their head regardless of all order and command structure, who and what tyranny is.
To say that they should disobey tyranny does about much good practically speaking as saying "Do Good and Avoid Evil".....it's a bit more complicated than that and guess what, human beings are social animals so we exist in hierarchies and in associations that are structured. That means we generally follow rules, obey orders and look to cues around us to know what to do. We don't expect a room full of sixth graders to rise up and overthrow a marxist teacher and we don't expect soldiers to disobey orders because "muh oathkeeper narrative".
Only legal orders, not illegal or immoral ones.
Soldiers don't determine what a legal or illegal order is for the most part. Just as law enforcement isn't going to argue the finer points of law while arresting someone they think is a criminal. Stop trying to pretend that every single person that works in law enforcement and the U.S. Armed Forces has to be a Constitutional lawyers. This isn't how life works. We don't go to our job with a lawyer attached at the hip weighing the legality and morality of every decision. okay, well, people who don't spend the day praying don't do that. People who pray unceasingly do that but spiritually.