I like etymology as much as the next guy, but to say, “fortify=tamper” but you’re really straining credulity here.
fortify has its own etymology from latin through French as “strong/strength” (see: Fortification, forte, fort).
I’d further suggest that there are about 6,000 ways to fortify something, from adding ethanol to wine, building a wall around a country, adding vitamins to milk, etc. Deciding that there is some root related to “to tamp” feels like a stretch. Suggesting it’s a “smoking gun” is kind of absurd.
Regarding the modern English words, “tamper” and “to tamp”, they aren’t related. “Tamp” comes from the French, “Tampion” or “tampon” (we use the same word to describe a different thing, but the concept is similar) derives from the tool used to tamp down powder in a gun. “Tamper” is first seen in the 1500’s as a migration from “temper”. It’s a verb that originally was just someone working on or with something and ultimate landed at the meaning we have today implying “interference.”
Beyond that, in the context of the piece, this article is not painting a picture that portrays the MAGA movement particularly well when you read the entire thing.
Fun little exercise in words and history, but far from a smoking gun.
Regarding the modern English words, “tamper” and “to tamp”, they aren’t related. “Tamp” comes from the French, “Tampion” or “tampon” (we use the same word to describe a different thing, but the concept is similar) derives from the tool used to tamp down powder in a gun. “Tamper” is first seen in the 1500’s as a migration from “temper”. It’s a verb that originally was just someone working on or with something and ultimate landed at the meaning we have today implying “interference.”
Came here to point this out.
Really growing tired seeing our beloved pedes failing basic analysis and reason checks. Even worse when mods sticky stuff like this.
It happens all the time. I don’t care that people make mistakes. I care that they are promoted by mods so when lurkers or newbies swing by we look stupid.
I get that good, quality posts take time and effort, and lots of us are so jonesing for new content, we consume more than people can create, so the mods have to “feed the beast” so to speak.
But in this instance there are better posts directly below the stickies.
I like etymology as much as the next guy, but to say, “fortify=tamper” but you’re really straining credulity here.
fortify has its own etymology from latin through French as “strong/strength” (see: Fortification, forte, fort).
I’d further suggest that there are about 6,000 ways to fortify something, from adding ethanol to wine, building a wall around a country, adding vitamins to milk, etc. Deciding that there is some root related to “to tamp” feels like a stretch. Suggesting it’s a “smoking gun” is kind of absurd.
Regarding the modern English words, “tamper” and “to tamp”, they aren’t related. “Tamp” comes from the French, “Tampion” or “tampon” (we use the same word to describe a different thing, but the concept is similar) derives from the tool used to tamp down powder in a gun. “Tamper” is first seen in the 1500’s as a migration from “temper”. It’s a verb that originally was just someone working on or with something and ultimate landed at the meaning we have today implying “interference.”
Beyond that, in the context of the piece, this article is not painting a picture that portrays the MAGA movement particularly well when you read the entire thing.
Fun little exercise in words and history, but far from a smoking gun.
Came here to point this out.
Really growing tired seeing our beloved pedes failing basic analysis and reason checks. Even worse when mods sticky stuff like this.
Every mistake like this is ten steps backwards.
It happens all the time. I don’t care that people make mistakes. I care that they are promoted by mods so when lurkers or newbies swing by we look stupid.
I get that good, quality posts take time and effort, and lots of us are so jonesing for new content, we consume more than people can create, so the mods have to “feed the beast” so to speak.
But in this instance there are better posts directly below the stickies.