Labeling people is not necessarily bad or evil; the worst thing that happened to minorities was their leaders easily influenced by Marxists. I am for Us being one but that means We help each other in the group and fight for everyone's interests. I agree that the American identity is the most important thing.

The problem I have with civic nationalism or even MAGA these days is that we haven't brought a plan on how we can truly save America and retain the heritage of this nation. Without American heritage, America wouldn't exist. We cant build our civilization if we are in the minority. Most immigrants don't assimilate and a lot of people in this movement or forum are fine with mass legal immigration even though it doesn't benefit us in any way.