Nope, what is "good" is a matter of opinion, and that is literally what philosophy and theology are, opinions by arrogant blowhards. They do not deal with objective reality, and thus everything they say can be dismissed. If they actually cared about reality, they would at least study mathematical logic, which is at least objective and reproducible. The people that study philosophy are people of average intelligence trying to convince you they're geniuses.
Undistributed middle, iirc, but this comment proves my point. The poster believes this is a "gotcha" question, because he knows philosophy, but not science. Logic is math, not philosophy. Philosophy may try to use logic, but every single piece of logic has a formal mathematical definition that exists independent of philosophy, and all ideas can be derived via logical equations. Philosophy majors think they're smart, but if they were, they would be studying logic in the math department, not smelling each others farts in the philosophy department.
There's plenty such as arguing objective morals and duties. I'm not ready for the argument and know it'd be waste to try with you anyways so I wrote the above. If you think science can explain why murder, rape, assault, and theft are always objectively wrong then go ahead and think that.
Nope, what is "good" is a matter of opinion, and that is literally what philosophy and theology are, opinions by arrogant blowhards. They do not deal with objective reality, and thus everything they say can be dismissed. If they actually cared about reality, they would at least study mathematical logic, which is at least objective and reproducible. The people that study philosophy are people of average intelligence trying to convince you they're geniuses.
Hercules was a man. I'm a man. Therefore I'm Hercules.
What logical fallacy was that?
Undistributed middle, iirc, but this comment proves my point. The poster believes this is a "gotcha" question, because he knows philosophy, but not science. Logic is math, not philosophy. Philosophy may try to use logic, but every single piece of logic has a formal mathematical definition that exists independent of philosophy, and all ideas can be derived via logical equations. Philosophy majors think they're smart, but if they were, they would be studying logic in the math department, not smelling each others farts in the philosophy department.
There's plenty such as arguing objective morals and duties. I'm not ready for the argument and know it'd be waste to try with you anyways so I wrote the above. If you think science can explain why murder, rape, assault, and theft are always objectively wrong then go ahead and think that.