104
Comments (27)
sorted by:
You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.
0
TheFreeSpeechRadical 0 points ago +1 / -1

you are the one laughable dude. see the responses on your other walls of text.

Being slain in battle as the quran clearly states has nothing to do with suicide. the act of killing one's self is cowardly and prohibited. the only case where a martyr is accepted in God's heaven is if they are killed in lawful battle. killed by the enemy not in suicide. the wording used is clear.

To anyone who reads these quotes they can refer to my other reponses they clearly state what war was meant to be fought and in what context. perhaps you were counting on my to be completly TLDR on every one of your copy pasted walls of texts... all I did is quote the quran itself. and nowhere in the quran it is stated to resolve to suicide, and to kill the innocent. the context is clear as day. it is only in context of battle on a battleground and away from civilians, and moreover only in self defense. furthermore it clearly specifies targets as disbelivers. not christians or jews. but specific disbelievers and hypocrites that are defined in the examples of the wife of noah and the wife of lot as opposed to the wife of pharaoh as a believer's example.

And again, you are a big liar. Sahih muslim is 43 volumes. where is this sahih muslim 55:93 ? where is volume 55 what is its name. Add this to the many times you claimed a quote in the quran from a chapter that had only 8 verses and you quoted a verse 23!! And you claim to be on a morally high ground and that any else than what you state is laughable. Sorry to tell you, I'm proud to have a pretense against your lying! you are lying to your teeth.

Also you claim that in Sahih Muslim 19:4450 that killing a man who was protecting his community give a muslim a double reward. You sir are a liar. aren't you ashamed?

I will tell you the story that is in sahih muslim 19:4450. Still in the context of war in the arabian penninsula in the time of the prophet, there was a tribe Khaibar that was a tribe of miscreants who killed and persecuted unarmed muslims who were travelling on their roads. One day, an early muslim called Amir was on his way in the vicinity of the domain of Khaibar, when suddenly the chief of Khaibar, came out and announced himself and proceeded to brandishing his sword to terrorise Amir who was traveling there. Amir who was a believer and didn't take any of that shit, so he decided to confront him in a lawful duel. they exchanged blows, but Amir accidently got his own sword cutting his arm artery open causing him to bleed to death.

And here I would like to attract your attention to the very point I'm making that suicide is considered cowardly and unlawful in islam. continuing the story, the believers told the prophet that they were sad, cause the deed of Amir will count as nil due to the fact it is a suicide. Here you have a prime example completely annihilating the point you make: that islam encourages suicide and makes it a good way to fight to fight. Here clearly, as Amir was thought to have killed himself and therefore his action is nullified. And so is the rule in any engagement. Any suicide completely nullifies the good deeds of a warrior. So please don't lie and say that islam glorifies suicide.

The story continues where the prophets makes an exception for Amir, as the suicide was completely unintentional and where Amir died accidently, even though he tried to engage the miscreant in a lawful 1 on 1 duel. In this case only Muhammad considered his attempt a commendable one and considered it to have double reward if the Lord accepts it.

It's funny how all the quotes you use, on further examination state actually the opposite of the point you're trying to make. You're very very fake news. your attempts here are as sorry as cnn's attempts on Trump!