3419
Comments (484)
sorted by:
You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.
1
Weremoose 1 point ago +1 / -0

Mass murders and genocides which wouldn't have happened had Germany not created the Soviet Union by toppling the Tsars.

And Marx was a German.

3
somethinga9230k 3 points ago +3 / -0

Mass murders and genocides which wouldn't have happened had Germany not created the Soviet Union by toppling the Tsars.

You don't even believe your own writings.

And Marx was a German.

Again, was Karl Marx not much more Jewish than German, with both his parents being Jewish, and having several rabbis in his family tree? Didn't he leave Germany and resided in England for many years?

0
Weremoose 0 points ago +1 / -1

Jews in Germany were German before WWII. He's certainly wasn't Orthodox, so saying he's not German is about as asinine as saying someone of French ancestry isn't American because they're not English.

"German" isn't a race. It's a collection of cultural identities.

3
somethinga9230k 3 points ago +3 / -0

And yet he spent many years in England, and Wikipedia indicates he was also stateless at times.

"German" isn't a race. It's a collection of cultural identities.

So, there are no ethnic Germans? It's just culture? Or are there no such thing as ethnicity? Or is ethnicity just culture?

You obviously do not believe your own words at all.

0
Weremoose 0 points ago +2 / -2

Ethnicity exists, it just isn't determinative of behavior. Culture and environment are.

Stop trying to dodge my points with this "you don't believe this" bullshit and actually make a rhetorical case if you want to have this conversation.