Catholics I know who actually live their faith wouldn't do that bc they genuine care about others. Plus your faith background is similar to Catholics in some ways bc both religions accept authority of both scripture and Church. Seriously try going to an adoration chapel bc that is where you would meet ones who are true to their faith and not just showing up at mass bc of habit. I was raised to be anti-Catholic but I met a Catholic guy who was actually a good Catholic as in goes to adoration, delivers communion to hospital etc... There is deep humility and strength in Catholics w a solid faith. Our relationship and marriage has been phenomenal. Better than I could ever have imagined. Wise ppl listen to advice. But you don't know me in person so can understand... It is the best advice I can offer though. Unfortunately, now many adoration chapels are closed or limiting visitors whereas before they were open to the public mosy hours of the day. Maybe online Catholic dating app look for women who go to adoration, but those women would probably prioritize Catholic guys. But good Catholic guys are hard to find so who knows. Best of luck to you!