4786
Comments (692)
sorted by:
You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.
-4
aparition42 -4 points ago +1 / -5

I believe it's a mistake for you to assume that all the people who didn't make it tried as hard as you do. Personally I find the very concept insulting. I feel no need to pretend that I tried just as hard at playing sports as the people who are good at it. I feel no need to spare the feelings of those who HAVEN'T worked as hard as I on something by allowing them to claim that my abilities are the result of winning some specious genetic lottery rather than as the result of me just working harder to get good at it than they did.

You can't compare someone who spends all of their free time living and breathing their instrument to someone who simply spends the same amount of time in the practice room or at rehearsal but doesn't give it a second thought outside of that time.

I have never met someone who was better than me at anything that they didn't also clearly try harder at. I'm comfortable admitting that I'm not as good because I didn't work as hard. Crying about "talent" is just a form of sour grapes for those who have decided they don't want to work harder than they already are.

If someone works hard enough to get to the point of comparing a second chair to a first chair in a highly paid professional orchestra, sure small genetic advantages may begin to eclipse level of effort, but when it comes to a college student dropping out of orchestra vs one who sticks with it, that IS a separation in level of effort, and frankly, I'd be curious to see which student spent more time drinking at parties and which spent more time playing their instrument alone in their room while no one was watching.

1
Nikola_S1 1 point ago +1 / -0

I have never met someone who was better than me at anything that they didn't also clearly try harder at.

Apparently you don't drive. Where I live, everyone who wants to take a driving exam has to attend driving lessons, everyone attending the same number and the same kind of lessons. Yet some people pass the driving exam in the first try, and some fail ten times.

1
aparition42 1 point ago +1 / -0

There is a huge chasm between "took the same number of lessons" and "worked just as hard at getting better".

Some people put in extra effort. Those who don't dismiss the extra effort as "talent".

1
Nikola_S1 1 point ago +1 / -0

No there isn't. There is nothing you can do while taking a lesson other than taking it. One person can't take the same lesson harder than another.

0
aparition42 0 points ago +1 / -1

You've never heard of "paying attention"? Some people focus on the task at hand, ask questions, take notes, and study on their own time while others daydream through the lesson, don't ask questions if they don't understand something, and don't give it a second thought after the lesson is over.