5222
Comments (549)
sorted by:
You're viewing a single comment thread. View all comments, or full comment thread.
-5
Shalomtoyou -5 points ago +12 / -17

Jewish in that he had an ancestor that was Jewish. Both his parents converted to Christianity and Marx himself was baptized.

No torah study.

No learning Hebrew.

No bar-mitzvah.

No listening to Fiddler on the Roof in the car when he was a kid.

Just some blood from some ancestor, and his own parents were converts to Christianity.

And wrote horrible things about the Jews in his writings.

Yet, you want to call him a Jew.

14
Pepe_Vult 14 points ago +16 / -2

Are all of the bank owners and media owners also just decendents of Jews and not practicing so its just a coincidence? What about the gun grabbers, like Bloomberg and Shapiro and Sugarmann, more coincidence? This seems like we are playing the "no true scotsman" logical fallacy instead of using Occams Razor

-5
Shalomtoyou -5 points ago +1 / -6

They aren't practicing. If a Jew hates Israel in essence he hates Judaism and doesn't practice Jewish ideology.

If a person who claims to be a Christian also pushes gay marriage, abortion and other SJW crap, do I blame Christianity? (And there is no shortage in that box).

Gotta hate Catholics because of Pelosi, yeah.

8
Pepe_Vult 8 points ago +8 / -0

So if i mention these Jews and their influence it wont be " anti Semetic " since they're not really jews?

-3
Shalomtoyou -3 points ago +1 / -4

Let me explain this to you.

Nancy Pelosi is, supposedly, a Catholic.

She loves abortion and gay marriage.

Should I get angry at the Catholic Church because of Nancy Pelosi?

Wait! The church itself is against abortion and gay marriage.

Nancy Pelosi is a bad catholic. But she is not all of Catholicism.

I don't know how much she practices Catholicism.

George Soros is a Jew by ethnicity only.

He believes in things that are antithetical to Judaism, just like Pelosi believes in things antithetical to catholicism.

If he took actual Judaism seriously, he would refrain from those deeds, the same as Pelosi would if she took Catholicism seriously.

Should we condemn Judaism because of Soros?

That's the logic you are using.

6
Pepe_Vult 6 points ago +6 / -0

No true scotsman

13
deleted 13 points ago +16 / -3
1
deleted 1 point ago +1 / -0
-2
deleted -2 points ago +2 / -4
0
MojaveJones 0 points ago +2 / -2

He's right, Marx was about as Jewish as Noam Chomsky.

Jews have 613 commandants to keep to get to heaven and us "gentiles" only need to follow 7. Gee...why would they discourage converts? Go figure

And the world is always so good to them too, why would they possibly engage when historically they always end up with people like you harassing them?

I hate how every good free speech site always ends up with anti semites hanging around. Please don't try and bring down a good site nazi boy

-1
deleted -1 points ago +2 / -3
2
MojaveJones 2 points ago +2 / -0

No, but a bit of Jewish blood doesn't make you Jewish. Have you ever seen Ethiopian Jews?

Noam Chomsky is no more a Jew than I am and I only have a great grandmother who was Jewish.

-4
Shalomtoyou -4 points ago +2 / -6

I'm not gonna look through the wide list of Jewish organizations. Do your own research.

Why do we not seek converts? Because we believe you don't need to be Jewish to achieve salvation. A gentile is considered among the righteousness if you follow the seven laws of Noah. Jews have 613 commandments. It is actually much more difficult as a Jew -- you'd be seeking a burden on yourself to become Jewish, so you need to approach if you seek that commitment.

We do not believe all who do not believe as we do go to Hell. That's the policy of Muslims and some Christians. And why you all seek converts.

4
deleted 4 points ago +7 / -3
-3
Shalomtoyou -3 points ago +1 / -4

I explained to you the religious aspect of it. If you're too illiterate to understand, that's not my problem.

Cedars Sinai hospital. Now F-off, because I'm really not interested in your tortured rational why that doesn't count.

7
Pepe_Vult 7 points ago +7 / -0

No true scotsman