A judge should be able to take a hypothetical and say something like, "Well given those parameters and some basic law I know from the top of my head I would say X would be an appropriate response."
Like different people can have vastly different answers to the same question I don't tink its unreasonable tbh..
As a judge she is allowed to explain her methodology for a ruling but she can't give opinions that demonstrate political leanings or else she risks being deemed unfit for the job...
she explains why she can't many times and the reasoning is sound.
Yeah, I agree with you.
A judge should be able to take a hypothetical and say something like, "Well given those parameters and some basic law I know from the top of my head I would say X would be an appropriate response."
Like different people can have vastly different answers to the same question I don't tink its unreasonable tbh..
As a judge she is allowed to explain her methodology for a ruling but she can't give opinions that demonstrate political leanings or else she risks being deemed unfit for the job...