Some people are getting the maths wrong on this. I don't think they understood the Lyndell video properly but all they've done is choose the curve with the highest correlation. You'll get a high R by default so they're basically tricking themselves.

It only started to get interesting when exactly the same set of points works on multiple datasets. They're doing a more advanced version of the mathematical mistake that Shiva made as far as I can tell and it's a distraction away from the real evidence that they have.

They do eventually start to apply it to other countries which makes it more compelling.

Some people are getting the maths wrong on this. I don't think they understood the Lyndell video properly but all they've done is choose the curve with the highest correlation. You'll get a high R by default so they're basically tricking themselves.

It only started to get interesting when exactly the same set of points works on multiple datasets. They're doing a more advanced version of the mathematical mistake that Shiva made as far as I can tell and it's a distraction away from the real evidence that they have.