Win / TheDonald
Sign In
DEFAULT COMMUNITIES All General AskWin Funny Technology Animals Sports Gaming DIY Health Positive Privacy
Reason: None provided.

You’re wrong. Note “and subject to the jurisdiction thereof.” Notice how the children of diplomats born in the United States aren’t U.S. citizens. I’m an attorney. I’ve read the constitution, I’ve read the case law that partially enacted birth right citizenship. The case that created it was very poorly decided, misreading an older case to come to that conclusion. If the amendment had intended to grant birthright citizenship, they wouldn’t have needed that “and”

233 days ago
9 score
Reason: None provided.

You’re wrong. Note “and subject to the jurisdiction thereof.” Notice how the children of diplomats born in the United States aren’t U.S. citizens. I’m an attorney. I’ve read the constitution, I’ve read the case law that partially enacted birth right citizenship. The case that created it was very poorly decided, misreading an older case to come to that conclusion. If the amendment had intended to grant birthright citizenship to be a thing, they wouldn’t have needed that “and”

233 days ago
1 score
Reason: None provided.

You’re wrong. Note “and subject to the jurisdiction thereof.” Notice how the children of diplomats born in the United States aren’t U.S. citizens. I’m an attorney. I’ve read the constitution, I’ve read the case law that enacted birth right citizenship. The case that created it was very poorly decided, misreading a much older case to come to that conclusion. If the amendment had intended to grant birthright citizenship to be a thing, they wouldn’t have needed that “and”

233 days ago
1 score
Reason: None provided.

You’re wrong. Note “and subject to the jurisdiction thereof.” Notice how the children of diplomats born in the United States aren’t U.S. citizens. I’m an attorney. I’ve read the constitution, I’ve read the case law that enacted birth right citizenship. The case that created it was very poorly decided, misreading a much older case to come to that conclusion. If the founders had intended for birthright citizenship to be a thing, they wouldn’t have needed that “and”

233 days ago
1 score
Reason: Original

You’re wrong. Note “and subject to the jurisdiction thereof.” Notice how the children of diplomats born in the United States aren’t U.S. citizens. I’m an attorney. I’ve read the constitution, I’ve read the case law that enacted birth right citizenship. The case that created it was very poorly decided, misreading a much older case to come to that conclusion

233 days ago
1 score