Ok, you’ve left the rails again. That’s not a logical conclusion.

• “Need” has nothing to do with anything we’ve discussed.

• Logically, there can be a word for hating all Whites even if one doesn’t exist.

• That a word doesn’t exist for hating all Whites doesn’t mean there can’t or isn’t one for hating Jews.

• I don’t see what the point is about “cudgels.” People can use words for all sorts of reasons. That doesn’t mean words don’t have meaning.

Here, are you arguing that Jews don’t exist? Answer that question.

If you say “no” then the word “Antisemitism” can have meaning, regardless of whether somebody uses it as a “cudgel.”

If you say “yes” then you clearly spend a lot of time thinking about a group of people you don’t think exist.

EDIT — I fixed typos at the end where I flip flopped the “yes” and “no”.

Ok, you’ve left the rails again. That’s not a logical conclusion.

• “Need” has nothing to do with anything we’ve discussed.

• Logically, there can be a word for hating all Whites even if one doesn’t exist.

• That a word doesn’t exist for hating all Whites doesn’t mean there can’t or isn’t one for hating Jews.

• I don’t see what the point is about “cudgels.” People can use words for all sorts of reasons. That doesn’t mean words don’t have meaning.

Here, are you arguing that Jews don’t exist? Answer that question.

If you say “yes” then the word “Antisemitism” can have meaning, regardless of whether somebody uses it as a “cudgel.”

If you say “no” then you clearly spend a lot of time thinking about a group of people you don’t think exist.